What are you reading today?

Oh neat; seems like Discourse has posted new polling options. :open_mouth: Iā€™m reading books, I promise. I need to make an update here soonā€¦

How much do you like each listed genre?
  • Fantasy
  • Mystery
  • Sci-fi
  • Comedy
  • Non-fiction
  • Historical
  • Thriller
  • Belles-lettres
0 voters

I wonder if the ranked choice could be a new way to poll for book club reads?

Which number is yourā€¦favorite? How do I use this?
  • 1
  • 3
  • 5
  • 7
  • 9
  • 11
  • 13
  • 15
  • 17
  • 19
0 voters
A new number-rating poll, while I try to figure out what a good fit for this would be. What is your average Natively reading level?
  • 1
  • 6
  • 11
  • 16
  • 21
  • 26
  • 31
  • 36
  • 41
  • 46
  • 51
  • 56
0 voters

They have some work to do on mobile. :joy:

3 Likes

Iā€™m getting that same thing on desktop. I wonder if the URL I added to the poll option is fouling things up?

2 Likes

Hmmm, Iā€™m a bit puzzled regarding the genre pollā€¦ I selected everything, but I cannot cast my vote?! Send hƤlp :pray:

4 Likes

I donā€™t think so? Otherwise they are wildly underestimating me (which I doubt).

I just read the first section, and it was weird, but nothing that would qualify as painful yet.

4 Likes

At the same time you donā€™t get the usernames hover any more when hovering over the avatars in the ā€œstandardā€ polls :scream:
Noticed that already a few weeks ago on WK but I thought that WK had hiccupā€™ed with the forums - now it seems that the update landed here as well. This change is very very unhelpful in my opinionā€¦

6 Likes

What does the number mean? Is it a rank (ie 1 is the best) or a score (ie 8 is the best)?

3 Likes

This is a ranked poll, I believe. So 1 is your top choice, 2 is your second favorite choice, etc. You can only use one number once, otherwise it wonā€™t let you submit.

5 Likes

Wait, no tie, then? Thatā€™s annoying.

4 Likes

People already have trouble picking a top 5. Good luck getting them rank every book or even just rank their top five in order, right? :sweat_smile:

4 Likes

Aha! That might explain thingsā€¦ :crazy_face:

But I must say I find the interface highly unintuitive without detailed explanations :thinking: I imagined I should select a number based on how much I like the options.

9 Likes

Sounds like an interesting option! Can you limit the number of non-abstain picks in a way? (And would that be necessary anyway?)

Oh but we would lose the percentage of all books, i.e. we wouldnā€™t be able to retire unpopular choices, I guessā€¦

6 Likes

If you select ā€œvotesā€, you can still see who voted for what with what rank. I feel like low popularity items would still be somewhat obvious?

Edit: maybe notā€¦

2 Likes

For the record, I donā€™t see a way to restrict number of Abstains.

I feel like the info given is very useful in very specific situations. :thinking:

Iā€™m also not sure what determines a ā€œroundā€:
image

5 Likes

If this is truly ranked voting, it works like this:

  1. Count up all the #1 rank votes
  2. If one option has a majority, it wins (plurality does not count)
  3. If one option does not have a majority, eliminate the option with the lowest number of votes
  4. Count up all the #1 rank votes, except if the #1 rank vote for a user was eliminated, in which case count their #2 rank votes
  5. Repeat above steps until a majority is found

The first round works like a normal single vote system (using everyoneā€™s rank 1 choice), and each subsequent round takes place after one option has been eliminated. In the real world, this type of voting system attempts to reduce ā€œlesser of two evilsā€ voting that locks in a two party system because people think voting for a third party candidate that has no chance of winning is ā€œwastedā€. Now you can vote for a third party candidate as rank 1 and know that if/when they get eliminated you still get to vote for one of the two main candidates. Itā€™s done via a ranked voting instead of run-offs to make the process more efficient.

9 Likes

What would determine a round in this case? Would I need to manually close the poll? Would it kick in only if someone sets an end date? You may not know, of course; just wanted to put the questions out there.

2 Likes

Enjoy!! There are certainly some fun parts, I was overly negative. :joy: I look forward to hearing your thoughts.

Important vocabularyā€¦ :smile:

8 Likes

One of the cycles @seanblue mentioned (counting everyone top options). It doesnā€™t kick in here since 4 out of 5 people selected fantasy (so it won on the first round)

6 Likes

It should all work automatically, updating after each person votes like usual.

3 Likes