Home thread - 俺の妹は悪女だったらしい vol 1 - BL book club - Reading now!

Welcome to the home thread for 俺の妹は悪女だったらしい vol 1 book club!

This book club is part of the BL Book Club.

Week Date Pages Page count End line
1 2026-07-13 4-37 33 と淑女らしくない声をあげた。 ***
2 2026-07-20 37-58 21 ニアはぶるりと身体を震わせた。
3 2026-07-27 58-93 35 ため息を漏らした。 ***
4 2026-08-03 93-125 32 End of chapter 2
5 2026-08-10 125-160 35 ぎこちなく咽喉を上下させた。
6 2026-08-17 160-195 35 End of chapter 3
7 2026-08-24 195-225 30 笑い声が震えそうになった。 ***
8 2026-08-31 225-245 20 ニアはパチリと大きく目を瞬かせた。 ***
9 2026-09-07 245-287 42 End of chapter 4
10 2026-09-14 287-321 34 ダイアナの高笑いが聞こえてきた。 ***
11 2026-09-21 321-351 30 ダイアナの高笑いが聞こえてきた。 ***
12 2026-09-28 351-386 35 ニアは顔を怒りで赤くしたまま足早に部屋から出ていった。 ***
13 2026-10-05 386-415 29 End of chapter 6
14 2026-10-12 415-456 41 叫ぶ民衆の声が空高く響き渡った。 ***
15 2026-10-19 456-485 29 End of chapter 7
16 2026-10-26 485-509 24 End of the first short story
17 2026-11-02 509-535 26 End of book

Discussion Guidelines

  • All plot-related comments should be covered with the spoiler blur or with “hide details”.
  • When discussing a specific section, please mention where you are in the book, ideally by chapter, so people reading different versions have a clear point of reference.
  • Feel free to read ahead if it’s exciting, but please refrain from spoiling ahead of the appropriate week.
  • If you have a question about grammar, vocab, cultural things, etc - ask! That’s a welcome part of the discussion too, and other readers will be happy to help.
Will you be joining us?
  • Yes
  • Maybe
  • I’m planning to read at my own pace
  • I’m just here for the discussion
0 voters
How will you be reading?
  • Physical
  • Digital
0 voters
1 Like

Thread’s emoji recommendations are currently open :smiley:

The book is on the longer side - Kindle lists it as 536 pages, this will be a long one.
I’ve scaled PC Kindle to the scale of the page listing so we’d have this conversation in peace. Depending on your scale (or physical book font size) the amount of pages may differ.

The structure of the book:

Chapter Start page Length (pages)
1 4 81
2 85 40
3 125 70
4 195 92
5 287 76
6 363 52
7 415 71
Epilogue 486 16
Short stories and afterwrord 502 34
End of book 536

How fast would you like to go?

  • ~40 pages/week (14 weeks)
  • ~35 pages/week (16 weeks)
  • ~30 pages/week (18 weeks)
  • ~25 pages per week (22 weeks)
0 voters

When would you like to start?

  • July 13
  • July 20
  • July 27
  • August 3
0 voters
2 Likes

Book club admin question.

How would you prefer the threads organized?

  • Run all in one thread, as eefara did for our previous book
  • Create a thread per chapter (if a week ends 5 pages into the next chapter, set up next chapter’s thread then)
  • Create a thread per week
0 voters
1 Like

I’m going to defer my answer to this one until we see how many people are interested in joining first. :thinking:

3 Likes

I’d love to join, but I’ve been so bad with keeping up with book clubs (or even reading in general) this year that I really don’t think I can promise anything :frowning: It sounds like a really fun book, though.

5 Likes

Same for me. I do hope to read it, but I don’t want to officially commit if that makes sense.. especially since I’m not sure I can keep up with a pace of 30+ pages a week (but I also don’t want to slow everyone down)

5 Likes

Our start date poll is at a full standstill :joy_cat: If anyone is waiting for a physical book (or wants to veto the date) shout. Otherwise we’ll start on July 13.

The pace is voted to be 35 pages. I’ll remind everyone already that it’s ok to go slower/catchup when you have time, etc.

I’ll be sure to mention on appropriate weeks when we hit chapter end to make it easier for the strongest of us that prefer to read chapter at a time.

Schedule is coming up.

5 Likes

I am mostly just a lurker in bookclubs but I do enjoy reading ppl’s thoughts, so if you get around to reading the book later, you are always welcome to leave your thoughts in the bookclub thread(s) even if it has been finished already. :eyes:

4 Likes

The book is not being kind to me in its natural separators.
In all instances of “20-25 pages or 43-55?” I’m choosing lower.

1 Like

:sparkles: Schedule is up in the home post :sparkles:

17 weeks; the last one is in November :grimacing:
We are averaging at 31 pages per week, and all but one break is a chapter or *** break.

I tried to go for 35, but to get there we’d need multiple weeks of 43+ pages. I’m not morally ready to commit to a couple of weeks like that in a row.

If you have ideas on how to schedule this better, now is your time to shine :grinning_cat_with_smiling_eyes:

6 Likes

No worries; thanks for your good work, Kroki!

3 Likes

Whoops, downloaded it as a pdf on Syosetu, sent it to my kindle using the email to kindle feature, opened it on the train after finishing my current chapter of No. 6 to start reading and the pdf was entirely blank other than page numbers :sweat_smile: Guess I’ll buy it to save myself the headache.

2 Likes

Week 1 begins!

1 Like

That it does!

And more formally:

Week Date Pages Page count End of chapter
1 2026-07-13 4-37 33 と淑女らしくない声をあげた。 ***

Are you starting with us?

  • Yes
  • Not yet
  • I’m here for the comments
0 voters
3 Likes

Just started, no real spoiler, since it’s at 0.4%

I’m so happy that Nia is not super pretty and girly looking! I hate that in most BL the uke is super beautiful and fragile, so I’m really happy that he seems to be a very average looking guy. Let’s hope it stays that way.

5 Likes

Okay sure, let’s go.

2 Likes

*no idea what 伯爵 means*

*looks it up*

*still no idea what it means*

Nobility titles are kinda like fish names to me. What’s an Earl? I guess it sounds like they are somewhat lower middle-class nobility.

3 Likes

Lmao. I’ve been on an isekai villainess spree so I’ve immediately read that as hakushaku (finally I comprehend kanji) but that’s where my comprehension ends lol.

Translations are just sounds anyway :joy::joy::joy:
Fish names is the best comparison
(Sending it fast before eefara gives an actual explanation)

2 Likes

According to britannica.com, English peerage in descending order of rank (with royalty being above dukes):

I’ve heard the ranks tend to vary a bit in importance depending on which country you’re looking at, and I’m not sure if generic JP sword and shield fantasy novels ever have one particular country in mind.

Edit:

Kroki’s got my number. :joy:

5 Likes

Also sort of on the subject from my recent reading.

Are you all also seeing two koushaku with different kanji? Same pronunciation but different place in hierarchy should be illegal

4 Likes