Physical or digital manga?

since i started learning japanese my interest for reading manga has blossomed. i find myself buying the physical books rather than looking for a website to read on. maybe i like the appeal of holding a book in my hands and it’s easier on my eyes. however, i still have my phone with the dictionary pulled up nearby. translating comes with it’s issue as i can’t copy and paste but i’ve gotten really good typing with the japanese keyboard when i look up words now. another thing that comes with physical is the space you need to store all the books. i’m currently reading 光が死んだ夏 and wanting to read チェンソーマン next and i’m already thinking of how much space all the books are going to take up.

anyways, i wanted to know what everyone else thinks? do you prefer to read physical or digital manga?

9 Likes

Digital manga is definitely more convenient for look ups, and I don’t think I’d have gotten much into manga if I didn’t have mokuro ocr on hand. But I love holding physical manga in my hands. Shipping to my country costs more than the manga themselves, so I have settled with only buying physical editions for stuff I know I will love, or for things I read digitally and will reread.

5 Likes

Manga I prefer physically. Lookups are a bit more difficult though, but I just deal with the unknown words unless they really block my comprehension. I read novels digitally though, I just need the lookups there. Hopefully I can switch to physical novels in a couple of years. And that’s not even considering the import costs (which are even going to increase by additional 3 euros per book this year here in Europe)

I do find manga without full furigana to be particularly challenging though, because when I do need to look up a word to understand what’s going on and I don’t recognize the kanji it’s a big hassle. I got the first 20 volumes of とある科学の超電磁砲 | L29 in my bookshelf but am not capable of enjoying them yet.

So in short, I prefer physical but am kinda forced into digital books due to skill and money issues.

5 Likes

I am in the minority that prefers digital.

Conceptually physical mangas seem nice, but

  • The size is small so I need to struggle quite a lot to see furigana and end up looking up words that in digital version I can read
  • The paper is not white so the art looks not as pretty as in digital version
  • It’s way less convenient in commute
  • I’m reading a lot of manga so it’ll pile up very fast in the flat and I can’t really afford that to happen (or the extra money it’ll cost to move flats someday)

And I grew out of thinking that digitally I can read scanlation so if to pay and support author it must be physical books, which really helped me haha.

4 Likes

Physical manga and LNs the way. There’s nothing better than owning the actual book. I generally only go for ebooks - regardless of the language - if they’re at least 70% cheaper than print copies.

My advice would be to always go for full sets when buying manga/LNs though as that’s usually a lot cheaper than buying any series volume for volume.

About the looking up: I generally look up words using the app Makimono and if there are Kanji I don’t know, I use Google Lens to copy them into Makimono regardless of whether it’s a game/book/etc

Although there are manga series I’ve partly read digitally but I didn’t have to pay for them. On the Japanese play store there are so many manga apps by publishers that let you read whole series for free or at least read some of them for free, you can buy additional chapters/volumes but they also usually have ways of getting tickets/coins (which you need to buy chapters/volumes) for free by logging in regularly, etc

4 Likes

Manga or nonfiction with pictures, I prefer physical, but sometimes digital is more convenient. Manga art is much nicer in physical , and you don’t have to worry about scan quality. My vocab is strong enough that I can usually fudge through words I don’t know, in a lot of stuff I read now. So I do that when I’m feeling lazy. Nonfiction with pictures tends to just be too small on a screen.

Novels or nonfiction without many images, digital for ease of lookups, on kindle. Tho my ideal would be physical, and when I eventually reread マリア様がみてる | L30 I’ll do with the physicals. In general the less screentime, the less distractions, the better. Tho with Kindle it’s not so bad.

I luckily have the space for it, currently have 4.5 tall bookcases in the living room, and 3 in my bedroom - 2 of which are hosting English & Hebrew books (many that I need to get rid of), sheet music, and DVDs.

At least I know if I ever get isekai’d, it will be like マイン from 本好きの下剋上~司書になるためには手段を選んでいられません~第一部「兵士の娘1」 | L32 :joy:

5 Likes

I prefer physical books but that’s partly to reduce screen time since my eyes don’t work great with screens long term and I use screens daily for work so physical books give my eyes a rest but I also feel there is something to holding a physical book in my hands and being able to read it without jumping for the dictionary as often as I would if I could just click for it :slightly_smiling_face:

5 Likes

Digital for the sake of transportation, and I can hold multiple volumes across multiple series easily.

I generally read on tablet, but look up on another device, smartphone, anyway. (I now have foldable, but I still feel too small sometimes.)

OCR doesn’t feel accurate enough for me, and manual look up is easy to handle phrases and sound changes. Better dictionary app.

Nothing against physical, but I have only text ones, not manga, for JP, so far. Physical books might also be not very big, but probably good resolution. I can’t really judge on that.

2 Likes

I have the same challenge of reading books without furigana. I bought Skip and Loafer and then realized there was no furigana… whoops. Now that I’ve been studying for a bit longer now and have more grammar foundation and vocab under my belt I’m going to try and read Look Back. I still have yet to try and read a novel. Those still scare me. Which novels have you read? Any recommendations?

2 Likes

I’ve been reading novels for almost almost a year now and it’s still hard, but it’s far easier now than when I started. Truth be told, it’s going to suck a lot when you start no matter what you do. There is no way around it and you should just do it. Do it somewhat consistently and you WILL get better. The good news is, there are things you can do to make it a lot better.

Things that can help:

1. Read something you already know

The first books I read were the first three volumes of https://learnnatively.com/book/f265765d19/
The reason those worked for me is that I’ve seen the anime 3 times and thus already knew what was going to happen. I still got lost plenty of times but knowing the story made it manageable. I’m not sure if this is the best method, but it’s what I did. It’s fine if you don’t want to do this.

2. Read with a pop up dictionary.

When I started I read on reader.ttsu.app combined with Migaku. Migaku is a paid app but yomichan is free if you want to go that route. I’ve sinced ditched Migaku and started reading on kindle with this custom dictionary (Don’t worry, it’s not hard to install). A kindle is quite expensive though, but if you can afford it, it’s well worth it in my opinion.
Just before you look up a word, try to guess it’s meaning, especially if you recognize the word but just have difficulty recalling it, it makes it stick a lot better.

3. Pick an easy book

Everything is going to be hard at the start, might as well not make it harder than it needs to be. There isn’t a giant pool of lv 24-25 books on learn natively but there are enough to keep you entertained for a while while still being able to select for your tastes.

4. Reread at the start

The first 5 books I read, I reread every single chapter at least once. Even more often at the start. This helped me improve quicker during the hardest part of learning. The repetition of words and grammar points you’ve already looked up really help them stick a little. It also gave my brain some much needed breaks from trying to decode something new.

5. Don’t be afraid to translate whole sentences, with caution.

At the time I tossed entire sentences in ChatGPT (sometimes together with the preceding sentences for context) and had it break them down for me. I still use the translation software in my kindle here and there. Use this with caution though, translating a sentence doesn’t really teach it to you, but it can give you the context you need to understand the sentences around it.

6. Just be consistent, read a little often

I have a lot of free time so I read for at least an hour per day. But you’ll improve even at half an hour 5 times a week (albeit slower). Learning to read novels is a bit of a marathon at the start. Good news is, it’s a marathon you probably can take slowly.


You’re not going understand everything you read at the start and that is fine. It’s going to suck but it’s going to suck less over time. You’re going to be looking up a lot at the start and that’s fine. Not a lot of those words are going to stick and that’s fine too. I don’t use anki to learn new words while reading, you can probably speed up the process by doing so but you don’t need to if you don’t want to. If you do want to use anki, make sure you get the repeating words first.

I actually read https://learnnatively.com/book/e36155e551/ quite early (when I decided to take reading seriously back in May). So you CAN go with a harder book, I just think I should have gone with an easier one.

Some good easy books are (I can only recommend what I’ve read which isn’t a lot):

Or just look here and pick something that seems interesting to you.
If a book bores you out if your mind, drop it and pick another, you owe the book nothing.

Sorry for the wall of text. I only started reading books myself relatively recently so I really feel like helping someone else do it. It’s tough, but it’s well worth it in the long run!

If you got any other questions, you can ask me.

7 Likes

I am not sure if this is valid for imports from Japan, as it would be against the spirit of the free trade agreement between the EU and Japan.

2 Likes

Every news source I came across just said the tax is for imports from “Non-EU countries” so I assume it also hits Japan, even if it’s just as collateral damage (the stated goal of the tax is to combat stupidly cheap imports from China). Hell, even imports from America would be affected. Then again different news sources state different tax amounts and rules so it’s all a bit unclear.

I really hope you’re right though. Importing books is expensive enough as it is.

1 Like