Spoiling ‏‏‏ ‏‏‏

Do you want to read a book but want to ask about the plot first to make sure you won’t be disappointed?

Or did you particularly like/hate a plot twist and need to scream about it into the void?

This is the tread for you! Make sure to keep you spoiler hidden, though, so that people only get spoiled on purpose. For now, the only method is to use a dropdown (potentially multiple in a row if you want to hide multiple levels of spoilers). Example:

Book title

You are now spoiled

Even more spoilers

She dies at the end.

And, of course, please be nice!

7 Likes

The idea for this thread came from this discussion, especially since I didn’t want to derail more the original thread.

Here we go, then.

(Edit: I already mentioned the basic premise in the other thread)

悪食令嬢と狂血公爵

So, the first volume focuses on the count trying to get her to become his fiancee, despite the opposition of her father. On the surface, the problem is that

  • she has a bad public reputation, as it is known she eats magical beast meat, which goes against the precepts of the main local religion
  • the count has a reputation of being a bloodthirsty killing machine (due to his role as the leader of the army corps in charge of magical beast extermination).

That being said, since he is generating a lot of dead magical beasts while his people are having trouble getting enough food, even politically, that marriage is invaluable to him.

The real reason why the father is against the marriage

The titular 悪食令嬢 has a lot of arcane magical knowledge, which she got from the teachings of her dead mother (as well as her research notes), plus further research on her own. It focuses on a type of magic that has, a long time ago, fallen out of favor due to difficulty of usage. However, her mother made some crazy advances in that field, and so did her. She is using that magic simply to prepare the magical beasts and thus make them edible (otherwise, you’d get sick eating that kind of meat, which is why it became culturally frown upon), but she can use it for a variety of things, including offense. It’s like she has the knowledge to build atomic bombs when everyone else is at the technological level of bows and arrows.
Her father and the count realize that and both want to keep that for themselves. That being said, I think they both care about her and just don’t want that magic (and rumors of that magic) to spread.

Volume 2

The father is finally (a bit forcibly) convinced to let her go with the count and, after some traveling, they get to his fortress. The volume features a mix of them dating (?) and fights against magical beasts.

There, you have been thoroughly spoiled.

Ok, on why I hate

安達としまむら

I read those novels together with the anime when that one aired. I theme went on to read up to the then newest volume 9. Compared to manga I haven’t that many novels, so that’s actually the bulk of my Japanese novel reading experience.

I’ve bought the newest volume (10). But I don’t think I’ll read it because I in the time I spend thinking about the series in between the release of volume 9 and 10 I have cover to hate the series. Maybe it’s not completely fair to the series, but I’ve become really negatives about it.

People say it’s a slow burn romance. But after having read 9 volumes I feel confident in saying that no actual burning takes place. In fact, the fuse seems longer than at the start.

Yes, they “get together”. But that really feels like it’s because the MC has nothing else to do with her time or maybe she feels sorry for her partner.

And then there are glimpses of possible conflicts or plot points that just never get any continuation. Instead we get AU (alternative universe) and flash forwards (the canon status of which is uncertain) short stories that cement that even as adults, no progress in their relationship or any character development took place.

When reading, it seems like both characters seem to have obvious “flaws” in their personality. And you’d expect them to grow in certain ways. But that’s never happening. I guess it’s important to have stories about kinds of personalities without presenting those as flawed. I love it when introversion is presented as something that’s part of a character, not a flaw to overcome. But in this case I just can’t relate. And if the story isn’t about character growth it lacks something else to be about.

2 Likes

I’m not planning to read that series, so I went ahead and checked the spoilers for

安達としまむら

God, I hate those so much. Like, why am I even reading the book, if I am being told that nothing will happen later either :anger:. That happened in another series I read, but “at least” it was the epilogue of the whole series. 10 years later, they are still in the will-they-won’t-they state. Great, thanks I hate it.

1 Like

omg, does she even like the Count?

2 Likes

Edited

More 悪食令嬢と狂血公爵

Yes, they really like each other.

Edited to add: he only found out when he came to formalize their betrothal with her father.

Also, some more stuff I like

They are actually really cute together and they really like to geek about magical beasts (while the general population find them scary and/or disgusting).

On the political front, the Count (I should try to remember his name :stuck_out_tongue:) is also mistrusted on the political level because (by necessity) his army is made of elite seasoned soldiers who could just steamroll the rest of the kingdom if they wanted to. I wonder what will happen if people learn he might have weapons of mass destruction :crazy_face:

1 Like

@here you can now add real spoilers! See below:

I’ll be honest, I don’t get why you’d read spoilers. How can you want to be spoiled?? :tired_face:

5 Likes

Sometimes I read spoilers of books I assume I won’t read and other times I read them way in advance of whenever I’d read the book and trust my weak memory to throw away the info ahead of time

Thank you for spoiling us :sparkling_heart:

6 Likes

Like @cat, I read spoilers of books I wouldn’t read anyway. Also, it’s fun to complain about stuff. Like, this time around, I would complain about the plot of 獣人隊長の(仮)婚約事情 but I can’t even be bothered. Oh, I guess I could mention it involves borderline non consensual stuff between a 13 years old girl and a 25 years old guy.
It took me almost two months to read because I just kept rage quitting. The only reason I didn’t throw it away is that I paid for it…

Anyway, I’m now going to move on to better stuff (hopefully)

3 Likes

lol I hate surprises–plus, spoilers lemme know if it’s worth it and if there are any triggers :joy::joy::joy:

you’ll know if the book is trash if the resolution is awful

1 Like

I was going to wait until I was done reading the whole thing, but anyway, here’s my favorite retort in 草魔法師クロエ (so far)

(Note that it’s from the free なろう version, it might not be in the published version, or it might have been edited; also, it loses a lot of impact out of context, but still)

Summary

This exchange is between the queen, who’s trying to get the main character (クロエ) to get betrothed to the first prince, and said main character.

「ねえ、クロエ、あなたは王子と結婚してお姫様になりたくないの?」
場を繋ぐように王妃が私に声をかけてきた。

「おそれながら、私はすでにローゼンバルクのお姫様ですので」

And here’s my favorite reply in 砦の魔女 1

「よし、私じゃよくわからない事がよくわかりました!」

:rofl:

5 Likes