It’s been a hot minute since I posted an update, but I finished two books yesterday:
献灯使 | L39 and スレイヤーズ 1 | L36
献灯使 took a while for me to get into the story. I have no idea why it was in my wishlist either. But my spouse just brought the book home saying they were curious about the 解読 since it was from ロバート キャンベル. I have to admit, I didn’t recognize the name and even looking him up I was only thinking “oh, that guy from TV”. Still, since the book was here AND on my TBR, I just went for it.
On the one hand, I really enjoyed the writing. On the other hand, both the main story and the other short stories (except for the “play” at the end) end brutally as soon as something happens. Like… what? What happens next?
I’m not even sure I fully understood the end of the titular story. (Spoiling the end; read at your own risks) 無名 and I-forgot-her-name-already are lying down on the sand next to each other, things are going smoothly, then he suddenly changes sex (a phenomenon previously established in the story; due to “contamination” which is radioactivity based on context, the human species has changed a lot and people will change sex once or twice during their lifetime), thinks “fuuuuuuuuuu… please tell me she changed sex as well please please please”, looks at her (and is unable to determine if that’s the case), she misinterprets his action and leans in (for a kiss?), then he passes out. The end. What about… everything that was supposed to happen after (major spoiler) being chosen as a 献灯使? What happens to them? Also, (major spoiler)why did he even pass out? Is it serious? He has health issues; did he die?? I was hoping the 解読 at the end would give me some answers, but it did not and focused instead on the background of the story (and I really don’t care).
Still, I’m going to say that this story (and the next one; especially the next one in fact) are both better SF AND better Yuri than アステリズムに花束を 百合SFアンソロジー | L30??.
Speaking of that, I really enjoyed the second story, but, again, it ends right in the middle of everything. The setup was really interesting, I also liked that the spicy lesbian scenes were described through wordplays involving kanji characters and messing up their stroke orders. Then drama starts! What will happen next? Well, The End is going to happen next, that’s what.
Technically, that was also the case with the third and fourth stories, but I didn’t care about what would happen next, so whatever. I also didn’t get the point of the “play” (put in quotation marks, because I don’t think you could actually get actors to do it) at the end.
I also read スレイヤーズ 1 | L36 on the side over the past week or so, mostly because I’ve seen the series mentioned here and I randomly saw it on the shelf at my local library. It was meh, I guess. I remember someone mentioning that it felt like it felt like it was aimed to be a one-shot, and I also got that impression. It alternates between info dumps and plot “twists”/treasons/aha I was the bad guy all along types of moments, which was kinda weird. If you unpile everything, the real bad guy could have just reached his goal from the very beginning, before the main characters even got involved… so… then why did anything happen? Also, there were like 300 deus ex machina to move the plot along and a lot of inline onomatopoeia. Also, there’s a lot of katakana English in the story, despite the setup feeling like feudal Japan? Maybe “English” is the actual in-world language, but if so I missed when it was established.
I still gave the book 3* because it’s really easy to read, short, and still fun enough (even though I rolled my eyes a few times). I want to reserve 2* for books that made me at least partially angry or bored to death. Looking at my books in here, I feel like I’ve been pretty consistent about it so far.